Ryan Shawcross
There will be a lot of eyebrow raising with this name being suggested but Ryan Shawcross has been one of the most consistent defenders in the Premier League since he signed for Stoke City. He is known for his tough tackling and no nonsense attitude though he is susceptible to the odd mistake here and there.
The 27 year old Englishman would be an ideal player for Manchester United since he knows the league extremely well and plays for one of the toughest teams in the league. Shawcross started his career at Manchester United, he represented the U17 and U18 teams and this would be a fitting return for the Englishman, back home.