3. James Milner
The new Liverpool midfielder left Manchester City, but the club did try to hold onto him and even offered him a huge deal, but he turned it down to play centrally for the Reds. Milner has often been rated as someone who can put in great performances but for some reason he has never been considered as one of the best. The fact is, Milner can be a match winner on his day but his willingness to put in that extra 15% for the team makes him a star. His alternate twitter handle might provide more fun than his regular one, but he certainly is one of the most underrated premier league players.