3. Defensive Contribution

This is one area where Valencia is better than Lennon. This season, Valencia has made 7 blocks, 36 interceptions and 25 clearances compared to Lennon’s 1 block, 11 clearances and 13 interceptions. The numbers were similar last season as well – Valencia made 2 blocks, 24 interceptions and 27 clearances compared to Lennon’s 4 block, 20 clearances and 28 interceptions.

In terms of tackling as well, Valencia’s numbers are better. This season, Valencia has won 40% of the 70 tackles that he attempted while he won 64% of the 70 tackles he attempted last season. Compared to that, this season Lennon has won 49% of the 41 tackles that he attempted while he won 52% of the 56 tackles he attempted last season.

The Verdict

Offensively, Aaron Lennon is definitely an upgrade on Antonio Valencia as he uses his trickery and pace to get past fullbacks and as a result creates more chance for his team. However, defensively, Valencia contributes more to the team’s cause. Now, it will be up to David Moyes to decide whether he would like to upgrade his offensive unit at the cost of defensive contribution or not.